In a scathing and shoot-from-the-hip article entitled, "An Alien by Any Other Name: Debunking a New Attempt to Re-Write the Original Language of the Alien Tort Statute," Rick Herz and Lorraine Leete attack  M. Anderson Berry's "Whether Foreigner or Alien: A New Look at the Original Language of the Alien Tort Statute," 27 Berkeley J. of Int’l. L. 316 (2009). See BJIL's online publication, Publicist, Vol. 7, Winter 2011.